Bill Gates faces climate accountability questions over $29-billion landfill investment

0
21

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates is facing renewed scrutiny over his climate advocacy after an investigation by ProPublica revealed that he holds an estimated 38% stake, valued at $29 billion, in Republic Services, one of the largest landfill operators in the United States, whose facilities have repeatedly been flagged by environmental inspectors for excessive methane emissions.

The November 10 investigation by reporter Alex Cuadros found that the investment has generated approximately $2.6 billion in dividends for Gates, while Republic Services has faced questions over its environmental performance and opposition to policies intended to reduce pollution from landfills.

According to ProPublica’s analysis of US Environmental Protection Agency inspection reports, inspectors examined at least 39 of Republic’s approximately 200 landfill facilities between 2020 and 2026. They documented more than 1,400 locations where methane was escaping at levels exceeding federal limits. In some instances, concentrations reached 100 to 300 times the regulatory limit, creating potential explosion hazards.

One facility identified in the investigation was the McCarty Road Landfill in Houston, Texas, where the EPA documented problems involving methane detection, flooded gas wells, erosion and inadequate maintenance of the gas collection system. The agency subsequently issued Republic a formal finding of violation over alleged failures to detect excessive emissions.

Republic Services spokesperson Rob Litt told ProPublica that the company employs hundreds of environmental managers and engineers and works to address problems identified during inspections. He maintained that environmental protection is part of the company’s business.

The investigation also questioned Republic’s progress toward its climate commitments. Although the company joined the Science Based Targets initiative in 2019 and pledged to reduce emissions by 35% by 2030, it has not adopted the initiative’s more ambitious updated target. A former employee told ProPublica that meeting the newer goal could require more than $1 billion in additional spending on landfill gas collection systems and other improvements.

Republic has also faced criticism over its industry’s lobbying against stricter environmental regulations, including proposals to divert food scraps and other organic waste away from landfills. Such measures could reduce methane production by preventing biodegradable materials from decomposing underground.

Gates did not respond to repeated requests for comment from ProPublica regarding his investment. His longtime investment manager, Michael Larson, also did not respond to inquiries. Larson joined Republic’s board in 2009, and ProPublica reported that he and other individuals connected to Gates participate in board discussions.

The investment dates back to November 1999, when Gates acquired approximately 5% of Republic’s shares through his investment operation. His stake subsequently grew as the company’s stock value increased. At the time, Gates was primarily focused on managing his personal fortune, before becoming a prominent advocate for climate action.

The findings have drawn attention to the contrast between Gates’ public climate advocacy and his financial interests in an industry responsible for significant greenhouse gas emissions.

Gates became a leading private-sector voice on climate action in 2015, when he launched Breakthrough Energy to support the development of technologies aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. He also backed international initiatives to increase investment in clean energy innovation.

Methane, the principal greenhouse gas associated with decomposing organic waste, is a major contributor to global warming. The United Nations Environment Programme estimates that it traps approximately 80 times more heat than carbon dioxide over a 20-year period and contributes to roughly one-third of current global warming.

Landfills generate methane when food scraps, paper and other biodegradable materials break down without oxygen. Capturing the gas can reduce emissions, but inadequate collection systems and poor maintenance can allow substantial quantities to escape into the atmosphere.

The environmental concerns surrounding landfills have also prompted countries to pursue alternatives to conventional waste disposal. ProPublica cited Germany’s restrictions on burying biodegradable waste, introduced beginning in 1993, as an example. The country’s landfill methane emissions subsequently declined by more than 90%, compared with an approximately 40% reduction in the United States over a similar period.

The investigation raises broader questions about corporate responsibility, environmental regulation and the influence of major investors in industries contributing to climate change, particularly when those investors publicly advocate for stronger climate action.

Author profile

Edgardo Hernal started college at UP Diliman and received his BA in Economics from San Sebastian College, Manila, and Masters in Information Systems Management from Keller Graduate School of Management of DeVry University in Oak Brook, IL. He has 25 years of copy editing and management experience at Thomson West, a subsidiary of Thomson Reuters.

LEAVE A REPLY