Van Gogh painting valued at $180 million to go to auction despite Nazi-era ownership dispute 

0
50

NEW YORK, United States | Sotheby’s will proceed with the auction of a Vincent van Gogh painting estimated at US$180 million despite a last-minute challenge from descendants of its former Jewish owner, who claim the artwork was sold under financial pressure caused by Nazi persecution in the 1930s.

The auction of Châtaigniers en fleurs (Chestnut Trees in Blossom), scheduled for Wednesday, November 18, in New York, could set a new auction record for the Dutch artist. The dispute centers on whether the 1936 sale of the painting by the family of German publisher Samuel Fischer was genuinely voluntary or driven by the economic pressures and persecution imposed by Nazi Germany.

According to Agence France-Presse (AFP), Sotheby’s confirmed on November 16 that the sale would proceed as scheduled. The auction house said it had conducted extensive research into the painting’s ownership history but had not established that the artwork was sold under duress or below its fair market value.

Sotheby’s also confirmed that it remained in discussions with the Fischer heirs and was committed to finding a mutually satisfactory resolution.

The family’s Berlin-based lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, has urged the auction house to establish that the 1936 transaction took place at market value and that the family would have sold the painting even without Nazi persecution. The heirs are seeking a fair resolution rather than allowing the disputed history to go unaddressed before the auction.

Fischer, a prominent Jewish publisher who founded S. Fischer Verlag, acquired the painting in 1909. After his death in 1934, his son-in-law, Gottfried Bermann Fischer, took responsibility for the publishing business and the family’s collection.

As the Nazi regime intensified its persecution of Jews, the publishing house faced restrictions because several of its prominent authors, including Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse, were blacklisted. Bermann Fischer left Berlin for Vienna, while the family faced financial difficulties and was required to pay the so-called Reich flight tax imposed on Jews leaving Germany with their assets.

The painting had been deposited with an art dealer in Amsterdam in 1932 or 1933. It was sold in June 1936 for 68,000 Swiss francs to French collectors Marcel and Henriette Kapferer. The Fischer heirs argue that the family’s financial difficulties under Nazi rule influenced the decision to sell.

Sotheby’s maintains that its research has not established evidence of coercion. The auction house’s position is that the transaction took place in the Netherlands, outside Nazi-controlled Germany, although the heirs argue that the circumstances surrounding the family’s departure from Germany must also be considered.

The dispute highlights the continuing international effort to address the ownership of artworks sold or confiscated during the Holocaust. The 1998 Washington Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art established non-binding guidelines encouraging the identification of looted artworks and fair, just solutions for former Jewish owners and their heirs. The 2009 Terezin Declaration further recognized the importance of addressing not only outright confiscations but also forced sales and transactions made under duress.

The issue has figured in other restitution cases. In 2022, France returned a painting by Austrian artist Gustav Klimt to the heirs of a Jewish family after authorities recognized that it had been sold under pressure following Nazi Germany’s annexation of Austria. In 2023, Christie’s also cancelled an auction of approximately 300 pieces of jewelry from the collection of Heidi Horten amid criticism over the origins of her husband’s wealth and his acquisition of businesses during the Nazi era.

Van Gogh painted Châtaigniers en fleurs in 1890 in Auvers-sur-Oise, France, during the final months of his life. The work depicts a flowering chestnut tree with figures walking along a street beneath its branches. The artist died in July of that year, aged 37.

The painting is part of the Blaquier-Arrieta Collection, assembled by late Argentine businessman Carlos Pedro Blaquier and his wife, Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier. It is among 12 Impressionist and Post-Impressionist works being offered by Sotheby’s, with the collection carrying a combined estimated value approaching US$450 million, according to the Associated Press.

If the Van Gogh painting reaches its US180 million estimate, it would surpass the artist’s existing auction record of approximately US117 million, set by Verger avec cyprès (Orchard with Cypresses), sold in 2022.

The planned sale raises broader questions about the responsibility of auction houses to examine the historical circumstances behind artworks, particularly those that changed hands during periods of persecution and forced displacement. For the Fischer heirs, the issue is not simply the painting’s present market value but whether its 1936 sale can be separated from the circumstances that forced their family to leave Nazi Germany.

Author profile
Paraluman P. Funtanilla
Contributing Editor

Paraluman P. Funtanilla is Tutubi News Magazine's Marketing Specialist and is a Contributing Editor.  She finished her degree in Communication Arts in De La Salle Lipa. She has worked as a Digital Marketer for start-up businesses and small business spaces for the past two years. She has earned certificates from Coursera on Brand Management: Aligning Business Brand and Behavior and Viral Marketing and How to Craft Contagious Content. She also worked with Asia Express Romania TV Show.

LEAVE A REPLY